News of interest to former Christians


AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Study suggests Israelites may have eaten hallucinogens, but scholars scoff

JERUSALEM - When Moses brought the Ten Commandments down from Mount Sinai, he may have been high on a hallucinogenic plant, according to a new study by an Israeli psychology professor.

Writing in the British philosophy journal Time and Mind, Benny Shanon of Jerusalem’s Hebrew University said two plants in the Sinai desert contain the same psychoactive molecules as those found in plants from which the powerful Amazonian hallucinogenic brew ayahuasca is prepared.

The thunder, lightning and blaring of a trumpet which the Book of Exodus says emanated from Mount Sinai could just have been the imaginings of a people in an “altered state of awareness,” Shanon hypothesized.

“In advanced forms of ayahuasca inebriation, the seeing of light is accompanied by profound religious and spiritual feelings,” Shanon wrote.

“On such occasions, one often feels that in seeing the light, one is encountering the ground of all Being ... many identify this power as God.”

Shanon wrote that he was very familiar with the affects of the ayahuasca plant, having “partaken of the ... brew about 160 times in various locales and contexts.”

He said one of the psychoactive plants, harmal, found in the Sinai and elsewhere in the Middle East, has long been regarded by Jews in the region as having magical and curative powers.

Shanon acknowledged that he had "no direct proof of this interpretation" and said such proof cannot be expected.

Biblical scholars scoffed at Shanon's suggestion. Orthodox rabbi Yuval Sherlow told Israel Radio: “The Bible is trying to convey a very profound event. We have to fear not for the fate of the biblical Moses, but for the fate of science.”

The full article by Shanon, Biblical Entheogens: a Speculative Hypothesisis, is available in .pdf format and may be downloaded by clicking here.

STORY LINK
 
OpenID mizlee said...
Why create silly explanations for the behavior of a a mythical person?


Blogger Spirula said...
Well, anthropologists have noted that the use of mind altering substances are common in most spiritual/religious ceremonies throughout the world. Virtually all tribes and cultures used them. Hallucinogens were considered as pathways to wisdom, prophecy or the spirit world. Chrisianity made an alcoholic beverage (wine) sacred. (Sorry you grape-juice guzzlers. You have it wrong.)

Recreational use is a relatively modern thing.


Blogger stronger now said...
Since I deconverted I've wondered if the burning bush story was an allusion to marijuana use.

Naaa! That's reaching a bit far...isn't it?


Blogger AWLHEART said...
I'm with Mizlee! I feel like it's studying how the flintstones lived together with dinosaurs!


OpenID SeAnOshman said...
I don't get it. If god's ways are mysterious and he is oh so capable of all sorts of miracles, why do they try and find natural explanations for the "miracles?"
What does it matter anyway, you ahve to have faith, right? No natural explanations needed!

LOL!!!!

Trans-Man


Blogger Jamie said...
Frankly, I think this could explain a lot...


Blogger eejay said...
Jamie, I have to agree with you. The totally bizarre shit that comes out the bible, could very well have come from people that were 'on something'. Now that's something that actually makes sense.


Blogger Michael said...
Accidental ingestion of psychoactive poisons was very common in historical times. A common mold known as rye smut caused ergotamine poisoning, a chemical closely related to LSD. This may have played a role in many religious experiences -- and possibly the "Salem Witch" hysteria. Google "St. Anthony's Fire" for more information. It has also been speculated that so-called manna may have been a slightly-psychoactive mushroom.

I used to have a roommate that everyone called Moses -- it was even tattooed on his arm. We heard all the "Moses" jokes out there. I think that my favorite was, "Moses was never the same after God gave him those two tablets." Somehow that joke seems especially appropriate here.

~~ Mikey


No, Moses wasn't high on Mount Sinai.

But he was never on its lower slopes either!


This post has been removed by the author.


Blogger SamiB said...
It all makes perfect sense! The entire bibble was written by Hunter S Thompson in a toga! This explains the disembodied voices, the hallucinations, the bizarre assertion that woman was created from one of adam's puny little ribs? Hah! As if!

Maybe it also explains why the bibble is such a bad novel and in need of a good edit. Although you would have thought they would have got it right considering how many times it's been rewritten.

I'd rather read a Cormac McCarthy any day.


Blogger Lorena said...
It has also been speculated that so-called manna may have been a slightly-psychoactive mushroom.

For some reason I find this really funny. I suppose the though of seeing the entire Israelite population high on something is kind of funny.

But then, they would have to be on drugs to follow such a crazy religion. Even for primitives such as those of 4-to-5,000 years ago, Judaism seems like a belief system invented by someone who was at best crazy and at worst high on some hallucinogen.


Blogger Brian Worley said...
Now we know the difference between a regular priest and a HIGH priest! lol


Post a Comment | Create a Link | Post in the Forums | Permalink



The first 200 comments appear here under the article. If over 200 comments are posted, click on the "newer" and "newest" links on the Post a Comment page to continue reading the latest comments.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

  Subscribe to this post's Comments (Atom).
Subscribe to every post's Comments (RSS).
Quickly catch up on all recent comments posted on ExChristian.Net on the Recent Comments page.

<< Home