News of interest to former Christians


AddThis Social Bookmark Button
A pro-life activist banned from stepping on the grounds of St. Matthew’s Church in San Mateo after a controversy over his display of signs showing graphic pictures of aborted babies was arrested on Tuesday, Nov. 13, for trespassing on church grounds.

St. Matthew’s pastor, the Rev. Anthony McGuire, placed Ross Foti, 72, under citizen’s arrest when he came for the 8:15 a.m. Mass on Tuesday, the Nov. 14 Oakland Tribune reported. San Mateo police arrived and cited Foti for misdemeanor trespassing and released him. Foti has been ordered to appear in San Mateo County Superior Court on Dec. 27.

Foti expressed surprise at his arrest to the Tribune, saying he had attended two Masses at St. Matthew’s on the previous Saturday and had received communion from McGuire. McGuire told the newspaper that he had been unable to do anything about Foti’s Saturday appearance, since Foti had left the church before McGuire could speak with him.

Foti, a well-known pro-life activist, has long been controversial at St. Matthew’s. Parents of children at the parish school began complaining last year of Foti’s truck, displaying the graphic signs, which he parked on a public street adjacent to the school. Parents, who dropped their children off on the street for school, complained that their children had to view the graphic pictures.

Foti told California Catholic Daily in October that he parked his truck on the street adjacent to the church only three days a week, when he attended Mass before going to San Mateo’s Planned Parenthood clinic. McGuire, however, said that, beginning this school year, Foti parked his truck on the street every weekday morning.

McGuire told Foti he could no longer come to the parish after he, according to the priest, reneged on an agreement not to attend the Friday morning children’s Mass. Foti claimed that McGuire had said the ban was not permanent, a claim McGuire denied. Part of the agreement was that Foti cover the offending signs on his truck; but, later, McGuire requested that Foti also cover up the signs that simply said, “Abortion is murder.” (See “An aborted baby’s head” and “Picture of an aborted baby’s head,” Oct. 1-2 California Catholic Daily.)

Foti told the Nov. 14 Tribune he did not feel McGuire “had any valid grounds to ban me from the church. Right now, I am going to call my attorney and see what I can do and what I should do."

STORY LINK
 
Anonymous telesmith said...
A priest arresting one of the Lard's soldiers for doing His work? Surely Gawd will frown one this.

I wonder if the pope would be willing to proclaim just how many days in purgatory this priest racked up for interfering with the "Gospel of life".


Anonymous Anonymous said...
This may seem weird, but I have highly ambiguous feelings about this.
The guy didn't attack anyone. He didn't try to blow up a clinic. He merely showed off a nasty truth.

I used to be more in favor of abortion, but lately, I've been coming around to the notion that maybe, just maybe, a late-term abortion really is infanticide.

I mean, it doesn't magically become a child during birth. A fetus, or, I guess, a pre-natal baby, has a consciousness, dreams, feels pain, in short, is a human being.

But it can get killed without questions asked, basically. That's kind of weird.

So, what I guess I am trying to say is that I think the guy is right.
I mean, we ex-Christians are all about facing the truth, not covering it up. We shouldn't cover this up.

-Leonard


Anonymous FormerFollower said...
Ok, so this old guy broke his promise not to attend a children's mass, offended many people in the congregation, and ended up being shuffled off for trespass, and now HE wants to hire an attorney? Good grief. Some things are just a no-brainer. Whatever your feelings on abortion might be, it is inappropriate to show little kids pictures of bloody fetuses. If you must proselytize, do so with the adults who can better handle this sort of offensive advertising. I think the priest did the right thing, and I can't remember the last time I said that!

I hear you, anonymous, but I still would say don't show those pictures to little kids. At least adults might be better equipped to handle that sort of thing, a kid just freaks out. The priest had asked the guy not to come to the children's mass for just that reason.


Anonymous telesmith said...
Besides poking fun at the somewhat paradoxical nature of this story, I have to agree with Leonard and add that the morality of abortion is definitely an issue that can, and for us unbelievers does, stand apart from religious ideology. Simply because one is not a Christian does not ipso facto make one a pro-choicer.

The fellow did trespass and that was what got him picked up. So, he got what was coming to him. Now, whether or not it’s appropriate to show disturbing signs to children or not is another issue.


Anonymous Anonymous said...
keep in mind this was in san mateo, california. i grew up in silicon valley, ca which is just a stone's throw away from san mateo. well, it's all the peninsula really. san mateo is halfway between silicon valley (for those of you who don't know, that's the home base for apple, google, yahoo, et al) and san francisco.

i'm glad there's still some sanity in this part of california, and a far cry from the religious craziness that goes on in the rest of this god forsaken country.

in comparison, even los angeles (the OC especially) is more conservative and plagued with religious fundametalists. pretty much all of LA except west LA votes republican as well.

so to me there's no surprise the priest acts with at least some presence of mind. it's northern cali after all.. we're not all crazy in this world yet


Anonymous Anonymous said...
I live in San Mateo and that church is only a few blocks from my house. I'm surprised I never heard about this, but not being Catholic, I guess I shouldn't be too surprised.

What does make me smile is that while the Catholic Church is staunchly pro-life, this priest at least had the sense to realise showing such pictures to children is inappropriate, and stood against this guy even if he may have agreed with his views.


Anonymous Eris Discordia said...
I totally agree with Anonymous on this one!

The pro-life issue is completely separate from the Christian issue, as far as I am concerned. For me it is an issue of compassion and morality which, most of you will agree, has NOTHING to do with Christianity!

Personally, when I walked away from Christianity I still kept my core values. Killing another human being is still offensive to me. Even if that human happens to be inhabiting a uterus at the time.

I also feel the priest did the right thing. It took a lot of courage for him to do the right thing and I commend him for that. As a non-believer in fairy tales I still feel we should judge people on their actions, not their station in life. In this case the priest was right and the pro-life fanatic not only broke the law but showed a complete lack of sensitivity for the children to which he exposed his offensive horror show. You would think that someone so concerned with children would show more compassion toward them!

It sure would be nice if all the priests had that kind of dedication to doing the right thing! Not just to please some mythical GAWD but for the sake of doing the right thing, period!

Also, If I were a parent of one of those children exposed to that horror I would be hiring my own lawyer and suing the hell out of that fanatical prick for traumatizing my kid!


Blogger rickyusvi said...
Leonard wrote: “I used to be more in favor of abortion, but lately, I've been coming around to the notion that maybe, just maybe, a late-term abortion really is infanticide.

“I mean, it doesn't magically become a child during birth. A fetus, or, I guess, a pre-natal baby, has a consciousness, dreams, feels pain, in short, is a human being.”


Late term abortions are a red herring. They're a rarely performed procedure used by “pro-lifers” to distract us from early fetuses who haven’t developed consciousness. Besides, even with the “partial birth abortion” ban, the primary effect has been not to save fetuses’ lives, but to further endanger their mother’s lives.

I do agree that abortion and Xianity are different issues. However, my deconversion education has shown me how much my previous anti-abortion position depended upon my Catholic religion, when, at the time, i was convinced that my position was purely scientific.


Blogger Rossi Foti said...
There are many people who seem to dispute my sincere belief that graphic posters of aborted pre-born babies do not inflict any injuries to children. Based on my 18 years of doing pro-life work, I have found that after talking to people that I have encountered, who are against my graphic posters, 99% of them are pro-choice or have had an abortion. These same people seem to have a bad habit of using the children as an excuse to condemn my graphic posters. The only children that are affected by my graphic posters are the innocent victims of the cruel, deadly, and diabolical act of abortion. I have had people who I had never met before come back to the abortion clinic years later, where I do my pro-life work, with there babies and tell me that it was because of my graphlic posters that changed their minds to not have an abortion. Also, I have had people come back and tell me that if they had seen my graphic posters that they would not have had an abortion. Really, my graphic posters are positive and serve to inform, to educate, and to give the people a chance to see for themselves the results of that cruel and violent act of an abortion so they will be able to make an informed and positive choice. The people of this nation should be fighting to stop the R-rated, out of control, bloody, gory, and unrestrained, graphic violence and that immoral, uncensored, explicit, and perverted pornography that is running rampant on our televisions and movie theaters. If anything is causing permanment damage to our children psychologically, physically, and emotionally, it is this type of evil entertainment with their nagative effects that is destroying our nation and the minds of our future generations...our children. Lastly, I am saddened and sorry that Father McGuire and the parents of St. Matthews caused me to be banned from my parish and arrested for trying to carry out the gospel of life. We must pray for them!


Anonymous Dad of St. Matt's kid said...
Haha. Ross. You never cease to amaze me. I'm the parent who kindly asked you to stop showing your signs to my kid because my kid was afraid to look at the signs when I dropped him off at school. When I asked him why he was afraid, he said he thought dead babies were in your truck. Considering your truck is plastered with 5 foot high images of bloody fetuses, his interpretation is not hard to understand. You probably don't remember me because so many of us asked you to stop. Your first comment to me was whether my wife had an abortion not whether my concerns were justified. I told you that I was pro-life but you said I wasn't and that woman had no right to kill kids. I found it impossible to talk to you because you care more about drawing attention to yourself than anything else. You made comments to other people at the church that the girls dress too provocatively. This is a Catholic school. You behaved like an unwelcomed guest and when you refused to stay away from the childrens mass (you love to go to the childrens mass- even showing up 45 mins before the mass so you could be there when they came in), you were arrested for trespassing. You caused a scene for months at the school, yelling at anyone who approached you. Why you refuse to believe that your actions hurt children is beyond me. I respect your views, but oppose your actions and your blatant disregard for the well being of my child. Good luck on your court appearance on the 27th in Redwood City. By the way, didn't you get arrested for hitting your wife in the past? wll you be appearing before the same judge. Do you feel that hitting your wife was rightuous and that she felt no pain?


Post a Comment | Create a Link | Post in the Forums | Permalink



The first 200 comments appear here under the article. If over 200 comments are posted, click on the "newer" and "newest" links on the Post a Comment page to continue reading the latest comments.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

  Subscribe to this post's Comments (Atom).
Subscribe to every post's Comments (RSS).
Quickly catch up on all recent comments posted on ExChristian.Net on the Recent Comments page.

<< Home