The gospel message that links God with dollars has been called to judgment before a powerful U.S. senator.
Sen. Charles Grassley (R-Iowa) sent letters requesting detailed financial documents to two metro Atlanta preachers and four other ministries nationwide whose leaders are known for opulent, or as the ministers would say, blessed, lifestyles.
Grassley is the ranking member of the
Senate Finance Committee and has developed a reputation for demanding financial transparency from non-profits.
He wants to know how much
Bishop Eddie Long of
New Birth Missionary Baptist Church in
Lithonia and the
Rev. Creflo and Taffi Dollar of
World Changers Church International in
College Park make, how their church-issued credit cards are managed and how many cars, planes and foreign bank accounts they own. He has asked for information on the ministries' boards, business relationships and associated organizations.
"I'm following up on complaints from the public and news coverage regarding certain practices at six ministries," Grassley said in a press release.
The other ministers are the
Rev. Benny Hinn, based in
Grapevine, Texas;
David and Joyce Meyer,
Fenton, Mo.;
Kenneth and
Gloria Copeland,
Newark, Texas, and Randy and
Paula White,
Tampa, Fla. All are well known in the evangelical religious broadcasting world. They are also known for preaching that financial blessings are part of Christian life.
"The allegations involve governing boards that aren't independent and allow generous salaries and housing allowance and amenities such as private jets and Rolls Royces," Grassley said.
"I don't want to conclude that there's a problem, but I have an obligation to donors and the taxpayers to find out more. People who donated should have their money spent as intended and in adherence with the tax code."
A spokesman for Long said that he intends to comply fully with Grassley's request.
Dollar said in a written response that Grassley is setting a precedent that would allow the Senate to pry into donations from any church or church school.
"Because of this fact, we feel it is prudent to consult well-respected legal professors and scholars to see what their thoughts are," the statement said in part.
"The questions are much bigger than World Changers as it could affect the privacy of every community church in America."
Dollar said his life and ministry have always been an open book.
Not so, said Rod Pitzer, who helps run Ministrywatch.com.
The 7-year-old group finds and asks for information on ministries and grades them on openness so that donors can decide where to give their money.
Many nonprofits have to file Form 990s with the Internal Revenue Service that detail salaries and expenses. Those forms are public documents, but religious ministries are exempt from filing them.
Pitzer said because of that, he depends on churches to voluntarily provide information. He has requested documentation from Dollar's church, such as audited statements or yearly reports. He has never received anything from them, he said.
Because of its lack of transparency, Ministrywatch.com grades World Changers an F.
"He's one of the few organizations that have an F, among about 500 that we are currently grading," Pitzer said.
Pitzer has not dealt with Long's ministry.
None of the six organizations that got Grassley's letters belong to the Evangelical Council for Financial Accountability.
It is a voluntary organization of more than 2,000 members that sets professional standards for ministries.
Ken Behr, its president, was an executive with Ford for 24 years. He called the letter from Grassley unprecedented.
"If they were [ECFA members], this probably wouldn't have happened," Behr said.
The agency requires its members to have independent boards that do not include family members, but do adhere to high accounting standards and justify expenses.
"When a person using a credit card turns in a receipt, they have to justify that charges were ministry purposes, not for a family vacation to Hawaii," he said.
Jill Kozeny, a Grassley spokeswoman, said the senators chose the six ministries because of reports from third parties, whistle-blowers and the press.
In 2005 The Atlanta Journal-Constitution ran a story that looked into Long's founding of a charity that paid the minister more than $3 million over a 3-year period, bought him a $1.4 million house and paid for the use of a $350,000 Bentley car.
Grassley's letter to the Dollars mentions information that Dollar tried to raise $1 million from other minister to give to Kenneth and Gloria Copeland for a celebration of their 40th year of ministry and that Dollar's ministries gave more than $500,000 to them.
Kozeny said, "Some of the accounts were of particular concern about lack of transparency, about how [the ministries] spend millions while you have it all exempted from federal taxes."
WHO'S BEING INVESTIGATED Sen. Chuck Grassley of Iowa, the top Republican on the Senate Finance Committee, is investigating the finances of six well-known televangelists.
The organizations and their leaders are:
* Randy and Paula White of Without Walls International Church and Paula White Ministries of Tampa, Fla.
* Benny Hinn of World Healing Center Church Inc. and Benny Hinn Ministries of Grapevine, Texas
* David and Joyce Meyer of Joyce Meyer Ministries of Fenton, Mo.
* Kenneth and Gloria Copeland of Kenneth Copeland Ministries of Newark, Texas
* Bishop Eddie Long of New Birth Missionary Baptist Church and Bishop Eddie Long Ministries of Lithonia
* Creflo and Taffi Dollar of World Changers Church International and Creflo Dollar Ministries of College Park.
STORY LINKRelated:Senate Inquiry Targets Televangelists Senator: Count preachers' blessingsGrassley probes televangelists' financesSpotlight on Televangelists
Maybe next time. But at least Joyce Meyer made the hall of shame. I've always wondered how much her fancy, shinny dresses cost.
....This years award for "Douche bag of the year goes to...JONATHAN EDWARDS!!!!" (Accepting for Mr Edwards will be Eric Cartman...)
They need to look at Pete Sumrall, too. I think things ain't been so above-board in South Bend since Lester went "home".
Texmex2003
You're becoming a troll. If you have something to discuss, then do so. If you are just going to keep posting incoherent combinations of words followed by an asinine "ha ha" all over the site, then your posts will just be deleted.
HA HA!
because I know what ex-c's responses will be like and i don't have the great faith to evangelize you all.
so do i have to leave? maybe... :)
Go bother Dan Marvin why don't ya?
I'm sure he would love to evangelize a new cult member like yourself.
Excellent idea!
This seems rather hypocritical when you consider their insistence on dwelling on the personal lives of sinners like gays, lesbians and even straight folks who enjoy sex outside of their approved rules for sexual behavior.
xrayman
All of these people are engaged in fraud, pure and simple. They should all be charged. If any one of us went out and took money from the less than brilliant, we would be charged in court and would have to pay huge fines. And how about checking on their income taxes? Do they pay any income tax? Are churches and religious businesses exempt?
When I was a Big fat C I can’t recall how many times I heard the phrase, “if I wasn’t a christian I would… (fill in immoral act of choice).” Well, now let me jump on board by saying, “if I wasn’t a half way decent person I would start my own damn money making cult”, being as so many of these bastards have gotten away with this shit for so long and are still getting away with it. Safer than pushing drugs and sure beats student loans.
Anybody up for some quick money?
No, Churches and Ministers do not pay any form of income tax. They absolutely should! If it were know how many billions of dollars Pat Robertson hauls in each week, people may be less inclined to send donations. Equally, if they had to pay fair taxes, they may find the whole business much less rewarding and find something more useful to do. Like pyramid schemes and chain letters.
Shame on me!
I bought from many like Joyce Meyer, which now I realize is a massive fraud, it is obvious to me now that these people don't give a hoot about Jesus and all that crap, what they *REALLY* want is the money and lots of it, even if it comes from those least able like little old ladies on the pension, let's make money! $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
One surefire way to test whether a preacher loves god or not is to see their objectives, many just plain ignore the verses where jesus tells people not to care about worldly goods and possessions and hoard them, what about the verse s about paying to Caesar what belongs to him? Meaning paying taxes like the rest of us.
I wish all these fat pigs get rounded up and executed for defrauding millions out of people, then again they are only half of the equation, the people who give money to them are also to blame, and yes, I was one of them thankfully it was only a couple of hundreds and not some big donation in the thousands like some fool with deep pockets gives.
He's always trying to sell prayer Shaws and prayer rocks.
The man who claims that God told him to teach us about wealth.
The guy never even uses his own bible. He just preaches out of the books about prosperity that he claims that God told him to write.
I am saddened to read how many people on this forum have admitted to losing their 'faith' because some "Christians" are wolves in sheeps clothing/hypocrites/scam artists. Is your faith that small? The Real Truth has nothing to do with these jerks. While it's okay to see them for what they are--and we have been warned, by the way--the Way, the Truth and the Life is still Jesus and Jesus alone.
It's bad enough to be cheated out of money, but it's worse to allow such terrible people to cheat you out of your salvation too. They aren't worth that.
Read the rest of the reasons why we left the faith. People like you come on here with the same crap about "You shouldn't have left the faith because of what "Man" did". It seems people like you make those types of remarks when you have only read a couple of posts on this site based on one subject.
The reasons why people like myself left the faith is not because of what some person did, it's the fact that your "Jesus" is a liar, and he never did anything to bring comfort and peace into our lives.
The bible itself is a book of lies, and I personally tried for many years to apply those "so called truths" in my own life, only to be let down by your lying God.
There is nothing you or any other christian fundy nut can say on here that all of us have not heard before. Quoting scripture from the bible will not make a difference, so you might as well do yourself a favor and leave this site. You will not convert us back. Several of us were once active christians who were once part of the faith, so we've already been there and done that.
We have heard all of the bullshit you christians have to say. Nothing you say is going to matter, so take your boring ass salvation message elsewhere.
If you continue to stay on here and debate us you will find out these following things:
1) Nobody gives a shit about what the bible has to say, and quoting scripture does not work on people like us.
2) You will win on souls for christ and nobody will be led back to your faulty faith.
So therefore, "Marksmom" you will only be setting yourself up for humiliation. You have been warned before you engage any further discussions about why "Your Faulty Faith" is the only way.
Some of the people on here are pros when it comes to defeating any christian in a debate. You cannot and will not win, so spare yourself the humilation and just simply mind your own business and stay out of other people's lives.
I personally have no desire to ever return to the christian cult, and enslave myself again along with sacrificing my own personal dreams just to please your false Christian God.
Jesus can stick it up his ass.
That's the way it is, so deal with it!
TO MARKSMOM:
2) You will win "NO" souls for christ and nobody will be led back to your faulty faith.
Sorry to hear that you are sad that many of us have escaped the Misery that you call being a christian. Seems to me that you are the one who still has the problem since you are blind to the real truth about the real liar who is named "Jesus".
The only "Real" Wolf in Sheeps Clothing who is a /hypocrites/scam artist is Jesus himself.
From Mandy to Marksmom:
Sorry to hear that you are sad that many of us have found true happiness and joy by escaping the Misery that you call being a christian. Seems to me that you are the one who still has the problem since you are blind to the real truth about the real liar who is named "Jesus".
The only "Real" Wolf in Sheeps Clothing who is a /hypocrites/scam artist is Jesus himself.
Just so you know, dear, I didn't "leave the faith" because of anything that any human did. I am no longer a christian because:
1. There's *no* evidence that any god exists;
2. There's *no* evidence that any part of human consciousness continues after death;
3. There's *no* evidence that there's any such thing as an "afterlife" of any description;
4. Give 1, 2, and 3, I'm tired of practicing superstition.
Rationality beats fantasy hands-down and walkin' away. You think you've got the Gospel? I've got better news: there's nothing you need to be saved *from*. There's nothing that could make me abandon the clear, warm light of reason for the dim, foggy shadows of "faith" ever again.
Faith is *not* a virtue - it's a character flaw. Grow up and get over it.
P.S Just because I'm a Christian doesn't mean that I should be broke, depressed and tore up. That's the world's definition of a Christian. They want God's people to live this way, so Satan can rip and run the earth.Driving a nice car, and wearing fancy close doesn't make Pastors criminals. If that's the case, then we need to investigate Senators too.