News of interest to former Christians

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Military officials in Iraq are investigating allegations that an Army specialist is being harassed for being an atheist but said Saturday that they cannot find an officer the soldier has named in a federal lawsuit.

Spc. Jeremy Hall and the Military Religious Freedom Foundation filed a lawsuit against Maj. Paul Welborne and Defense Secretary Robert Gates in U.S. District Court in Kansas City, Kansas, this past week. It alleges that Welborne threatened to pursue military charges against Hall and to block his reenlistment because he was trying to hold a meeting of atheists and non-Christians in Iraq.

The suit also alleges that Gates permits a military culture in which officers are encouraged to pressure soldiers to adopt and espouse fundamentalist Christian beliefs.

On Friday, Mikey Weinstein, the foundation's founder and president, released to The Associated Press copies of e-mails from Hall in which the soldier said he had been harassed and threatened on blogs with being killed by friendly fire for filing the lawsuit.

Lt. Col. James Hutton, a spokesman for the U.S.-led multinational force in Iraq, said in a statement from Iraq on Saturday that the Army was investigating Hall's situation. But he added: "Several media reports list a person named Maj. Paul Welborne as having been involved in this situation. To date, we have not located any soldier by that name."

In responding to the lawsuit, a Pentagon spokesman said the military does value and respect religious freedoms, but that accommodating religious practices should not interfere with unit cohesion, readiness, standards or discipline.

Hall, who is serving with the 97th Military Police Battalion out of Fort Riley, Kan., has been in Iraq since 2006, on his second tour.

‘I might be harmed or worse’

Hall wrote in a series of e-mails to Weinstein that he feared for his safety after being "hallchecked" — being shoved against the wall in a hallway — by fellow soldiers who objected to his lawsuit. Bloggers on the Internet have also referred to "fragging" Hall, or killing him by friendly fire.

"I hope I am not the victim of a hate crime while I sleep tonight. I do not want to die for my country this way," wrote Hall, who said a non-commissioned officer was threatening to beat him. "I'm doing my best right now. But I am still afraid that I might be harmed or worse."

Weinstein said Saturday that the issue was not locating Welborne, noting the incidents alleged in the lawsuit occurred in July and August and the major may have left Iraq since then. Instead, he said, the military must find the soldiers who are threatening Hall and prosecute them under military law.

"We're talking about stuff that happened 36 hours ago. If they can't find the people who have been harassing Jeremy, we will," Weinstein said. "This isn't that hard to do.

"If one hair on Hall's head is touched, there will be hell to pay," Weinstein said.

In the lawsuit, Hall said that his free speech and religious rights were violated a year ago when he sat down with soldiers to eat a Thanksgiving holiday dinner. When asked to join hands and pray, Hall declined, but sat as the other soldiers prayed over the food. A sergeant asked why he would not pray and Hall told him he was an atheist, meaning he does not believe in God.

The sergeant demanded that Hall move to another table and not sit with the other soldiers. Hall said he stayed and ate without speaking to the others.

Challenges to Hall’s beliefs

In July, Hall said he walked away from soldiers in his unit when a colonel wanted them to pray before they went on a mission in the city of Kirkuk.

The lawsuit names Gates as a defendant and alleges he permits a culture that sanctions activities by Christian organizations, including providing personnel and equipment.

It also says the military permits proselytizing by soldiers, tolerates anti-Semitism, placing of religious symbols on military equipment and allows the use of military e-mail accounts to send religious rhetoric.

Some postings on military-related blogs have been critical of Hall, with some people wondering how atheists can claim religious freedom if they practice no sanctioned faith.

One individual, posting under the name "Hidog," suggested Hall put on an orange vest and carry a sign "Bong hits 4 Allah" through the streets of Iraq, "because apparently, your Bill of Rights trump your CO's (commanding officer's) orders."

But others said the U.S. Constitution protects "freedom from religion," and defended Hall, adding that they were glad he spoke up against the pressures from some Christians.

Story Link

 
Comments:
Blogger Harlequin said...
The reason there are no Atheists in foxholes... they get fragged by their own side for not having an imaginary friend....

Nice!

Gramps


Blogger rossextian said...
If the idiots who are trying to turn our military into a theocracy, had lived during the Revolutionary War, they would have been fighting in a Loyalist regiment or even the British Army itself.

Many of the Loyalists were Christians who believed that independence for the colonies was against the will of God and that King George was God's appointed ruler of the colonies.

The Revoltionary War was fought for independence from a Christian nation: the British Empire. In fact the rallying cry of the Loyalists was "God save the King!"

Not all of our Founding Fathers
were Christians. Thomas Jefferson was a Diest and Benjamin Franklin believed in reincarnation.

But even the Founding Fathers who were Christians had the sense to realize that America had to be a secular nation in order to protect freedom of religion and freedom from religion.

The idiots who carry out acts of anti-semitism against our Jewish soldiers, are trying to turn our military, and indeed our entire nation, into a Christian theocracy, are an insult to what our country was founded for, and are just as evil as the Muslims who believe they have to convert or kill all "infidels" (non-Muslims).

Inquisition-era Spain, the former Soviet Union, and Saudi Arabia today, are excellent examples as to why the United States of America must remain a secular nation with complete seperation of church and state!


Anonymous Jiggs Casey said...
Big freaking deal.

I get harrassed at work for being a Christian, and the atheists have never come to my defense...in fact, they have joined in the ridicule.

Yeah, freedom of religion.

Of course, I understand now that an atheist does not think that what applies to him applies to me.


Anonymous ryan said...
I am surprized at what I have read. When I was in Vietnam I saw no sign of religion; nothing. And while I am on the subject, I was incensed, many years ago, to read that dubya's father, the senior bush, declared that atheists cannot really be citizens. I carried an M-16 for a year, waiting to get a new asshole,and I am not a citizen?

The US military is best exemplified by General Ethan Allen, who, according to legend, demanded the surrender of Fort Ticonderoga "in the name of jehova and the Continental Congress". He did no such thing. General Allen was an atheist who wrote the first anti-christian book published in this country: Reason, The Only Oracle of Man

And jiggs......too bad that you are shit on at work by atheists. Just what sort of dumb speech or actions has brought this on? Most atheists do not care what you do, as long as you stay in your church and play with your rattlesnacks and do not bother anyone. And let me remind you that your ilk has spent centuries tormenting and persecuting all those who do not believe as you. How does it feel?

And by the way, it's "big fucking deal".


Blogger Onanite said...
What a horrible situation this young man finds himself in. I tell you all that it make my blood boil.

These so called Xtians are nothing more than bullies with bibles. God I hate this country sometimes, but I hate Xtians more.


Anonymous Anonymous said...
If the idiots who are trying to turn our military into a theocracy,
Got some bad news for you. The US Marines are basically that, a Christian theocracy.

Brett R


Anonymous Rick said...
Brett : "Got some bad news for you. The US Marines are basically that, a Christian theocracy."

Too true, and not only limited to the Marines. The military wants a cohesive fighting group that works together like a machine. Religion fosters a group unity that strengthens morale and helps to maintain discipline. It is easy to create an "us and them" mentality - even when facing off against U.S. citizens. This is why hazing within the group can be so aggressive.

Commanders do not want their soldiers wondering if their orders are ethical, moral, or right, they just want the soldiers to do what their told and accept that those in charge know what they are doing - just like followers of religion.

War and religion complement each other so well its no wonder you find them in bed.


Anonymous ryan said...
Brett and Rick, I was just surprized. Now I'm disturbed. I spent three years as Regular Army, and did a tour in Vietnam. While there was some chapel attendance,both stateside and overseas, I can honestly say that outside of chapel I never saw a bible and never saw or heard anyone pray. The US Army was godless, period.

And now I read that even the Marines are giving their lives to jesus??? What's next, a born-again CIA???


Blogger Monk said...
I was in the marines for 6 years in the infantry. Religion was not a factor. SOME marines went to services for comfort, but many more found comfort in other places (particularly alcohol).

Marine Christian Theocracy??? Not a chance in hell. Puh-leaze.


Blogger pauzhaan said...
The major who harrassed Jeremy Hall has been located in Iraq.
His first name is Freddy and he has a public web page:

myspace.com/freddywelborn

The major (purposely not capitalized) doesn't leave any doubt where he is coming from.


Blogger Kennethos said...
Does anyone have links for these so-called Christian bloggers calling for Spc. Hall to be fragged? I've googled and found nothing. It sounds like Hall has come up with an urban legend.


Blogger Kennethos said...
Additionally, regarding Maj. Welborn (sp?), the burden of doubt is on Spc. Wall to prove that the major harassed him. Field-grade officers typically don't harass junior enlisted soldiers, even if the major is a Christian and the specialist is a Baptist-gone-atheist. JAG will have a field day on this, I think.


Permalink



AddThis Social Bookmark Button Vote up this article on the Atheist Spot

Subscribe to the latest Comments (RSS).
Quickly catch up on all recent comments posted on ExChristian.Net on the Recent Comments page.

<< Home
 
Click here and check out more books in the ExChristian.Net Book Store.