Laura Lopez wants dozens of books removed from two
Palm Beach County high school libraries because the contents address homosexuality, abortion and atheism.
"Those books should never be in the schools for kids to see," Lopez, a mother of three from west of West Palm Beach, said Monday.
Following Superintendent Art Johnson's refusal in March to remove the books, the Palm Beach County School Board on Wednesday will hold a rare hearing on the book challenge.
The board set aside 15 minutes for Lopez's appeal, which she's entitled to under school district procedures.
County schools receive a Citizen's Request for Reconsideration of Instructional Materials an average of three or four times each year, said Meezie Pierce, director of K-12 Instructional Materials and Library Media Services.
These requests are always resolved by the schools, making Lopez's hearing at the School Board highly unusual.
Lopez did not attend December and January meetings of committees that reviewed and rejected her challenges at Royal Palm Beach High School and Alexander W. Dreyfoos Jr. School of the Arts in West Palm Beach. Two of her children are incoming sophomores at Royal Palm Beach; one used to attend Dreyfoos. Lopez's youngest child is entering the fourth grade.
Dreyfoos Principal Ellen Van Arsdale, in a January letter to Lopez, listed four reasons for the committee's denial. Cited were Florida education standards that students examine "a literary selection from several critical perspectives," and a portion from a national Library Bill of Rights that "libraries should provide materials and information presenting all points of view on current and historical issues."
Two of the books that Lopez challenged are: Sexual Values: Opposing Viewpoints by Charles P. Cozic and Abortion: Opposing Viewpoints by Tamara L. Roleff.
"The Committee believes topics of abortion, atheism and homosexuality are social issues that high school students encounter in the media and in some situations within their families and social networks, such as in debate tournaments throughout the School District," Van Arsdale wrote.
Rand Hoch, president and founder of the Palm Beach County Human Rights Council, said he's pleased to see the district take a strong stand against censorship.
"She [Lopez] has been repeatedly turned down based on the principle that access to a wide range of information for students is a good thing," said Hoch, whose nongovernmental gay rights group watches school issues.
Lopez, in a January letter to Johnson, wrote, "I know that the Constitution says freedom of speech but what about my freedom as a parent to not want [my children] to read about abortion and homosexuality in their school library."
Lopez, who said she is a member of Christ Fellowship Church, filled out a separate request for each objectionable book. She cited biblical passages and called for teaching religion and allowing prayer in public schools.
Kudos to the Principal, the school board and the predominantly heathen teachers union for their willingness to stand fast against the growing tide of Christian ignorance in this country! She sounds like an anal polyp that just won't go away!
Next thing you know, they will be staging book burnings!
As a parent, I sympathize with Mrs. Lopez' feelings of being not in control of what her children are exposed to. What saddens me is that she apparently doesn't understand that her children would best be served by exposure to the very ideas she finds so objectionable. As Aristotle once wrote, "It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it."
Once again we're treated to a demonstration that religion is not about faith, not about relationships, not about love, grace, or salvation - it is about control. Fortunately, it looks like the school board is only following protocol by allowing her appeal. She's certainly entitled to express her views, but there are no reasonable grounds for removing the books.
"...but what about my freedom as a parent to not want [my children] to read about..." etc.
What about it? She's free to continue to not want it. Go ahead Laura, knock yourself out; the key word there being "yourself."
Maybe she'll get a message from Our Lady Of The Piece Of Toast on how best to handle her self-created problem.
- El Pastor de Anguilas
No one has the right to use their religious beliefs to limit other families' access to information. No one.
Well what about my right to have my children exposed to such things???
Parenting is your job, if you don't like it then you need to fill the roll...
However, rather frankly, I wish your kind would just fade into nonexistences...
I nearly did a spit-take when I read that, it is possibly the dumbest thing i've ever read in my life.
She wrote biblical verses,tut tut, and quote contitution rights like fredom of speech? how about freedom from religion!
Perhaps some scientific facts should be quoted in the meeting.
Agreed,as a parent, she wouldn't want a 'child' (under 14) reading a book of another opinion will make the child not accept the parents beliefs so easily (conflict of thought) or basically think beyond the biblical bullshit.
So, perhaps providing books such as these for teens rather than children.
So the real question is how old are the children and what can they read and understand.
Agreed,as a parent, she wouldn't want a 'child' (under 14) reading a book that has another opinion. It will influence the child, who may not accept the parents beliefs so easily (conflict of thoughts)or confuse the poor kiddie or basically think beyond the biblical bullshit, and achieve in life.
One word: homeschool. Problem solved. Oh, but you want the public to fund and carry out the education of your fragile children, but do it in a manner that shelters them from anything that you deem harmful? Sorry. No can do. And really, you think they will only learn about homosexuality and abortion from books and not from, like, peers the way most kids do. Really, this woman is clueless about kids.
And again, more proof that fundy Christians don't understand or approve of the basic constitutional rights of others.
Onanite
She plans to get a church sponsored petition drive going and seek out legal assistance from a christian law center.
Looks like the school board is going to have their hands full for the next year or two.
Her minister, support joined the conversation... it appeared that as soon as I started to use the bible to counter her own claims...they had to go.
Thank you WP School board for using logic and reason and a commitment to "liberty and justice for all" and for drowning out a squeeky wheel.
KenL, Atheists of Broward County
Really, when I first say the headline, I thought she was going after stories where gays and abortions were held up as the be all end all of how life should be lived. Not dry old text books.
Yes, but if they learn it from their peers, they will most likely learn that it is disgusting...which is the same thing that their mother, the church, and christians want them to think anyway.
As far as "Opposing Viewpoints" sounding too boring for kids to bother reading, you can bet they'll all be clamouring to read it NOW, given the controversy! This woman doesn't realize that she likely caused a whole bunch of kids who would never have known the book was even in the library to seek it out and read it.
Then you can "examine" every book that they bring home from the library to make sure that they aren't reading anything they shouldn't.
You could also try sneaking up on them while they are reading in the library to try to catch them reading something they shouldn't.
You could periodically go through all of their things looking for hidden books or magazines.
You know pretty much make life a police state for the little brats. Much like what I had to put up with growing up in Fundyland.
The bible has all the perverted content that she doesn't want her kids to read in the school library.